A gratuity is a voluntary tip owned by staff; a service charge is a mandatory fee the restaurant collects and controls, with different tax and payroll treatment.
Gratuity vs. Service Charge
A gratuity is a voluntary tip owned by staff; a service charge is a mandatory fee the restaurant collects and controls, with different tax and payroll treatment.
A gratuity is a voluntary tip the guest chooses to leave, and it belongs to the employees. A service charge is a mandatory fee the restaurant adds to the bill — common on large parties, prix-fixe events, or as an automatic percentage — and it is restaurant revenue that the business controls and distributes.
On the check they can look identical: both read as a percentage line under the subtotal. In the POS, in payroll and on the books they are two different things.
Why the distinction shows up at the register #
Take a $400 party check. A 20% automatic gratuity is $80 that belongs to the staff and is handled as tips. A 20% mandatory service charge on the same check is $80 of restaurant revenue — and whatever portion you hand to staff from it runs through payroll as wages, not tips, which changes the payroll-tax treatment.
That is why the two have to be configured as separate objects rather than one "20% line". Square for Restaurants documents them separately: automatic gratuity set either as a flat percentage or triggered by a party-size threshold, and service charges set as a percentage or a fixed amount. talech — now rebranding to Elavon Point of Sale — lists automatic gratuity on its full-service tier alongside coursing and pay-by-position.
One tax note worth knowing, since it turns on exactly this distinction: under the 2025 One Big Beautiful Bill Act, a federal deduction of up to $25,000 a year for qualified tips applies for tax years 2025 through 2028, it excludes mandatory service charges, and employers must report qualified tips separately on the W-2 or 1099 (per Fourth's 2025 end-of-year restaurant compliance summary).
How software handles this #
Categorisation starts in the POS and has to survive two more hand-offs — the tip distribution, and the ledger.
- 7shifts distributes tips by hours and role through its Tip Management add-on ($49.99 per month per location, bundled into the $149.99 Premium plan) and pushes the result into payroll, with connectors including Gusto and ADP.
- Heartland Restaurant handles tipout distribution and end-of-day reconciliation inside its POS employee module at $89/month per station, so the tip side closes with the shift.
- HotSchedules (Fourth) adds digital tip payouts after the shift plus earned wage access; quote-only.
- Restaurant365 runs tip pooling and wage calculation inside its own payroll module, which is the cleanest place for a service-charge payout to land as wages rather than as a tip.
Compare the labor side on the scheduling and labor pillar, and the ledger side on the restaurant accounting pillar.
Related terms #
- Tip Pooling — how the gratuity side gets split
- Tender — how the payment line itself is recorded
- Check Average — why an auto-gratuity line is not revenue